For information and reference only – not to be submitted as your own work.

This extract shows how a 1,000-word answer to the BED610 Ethical Principles for Educators case study can be organised around its four guide questions. The case concerns Maya, a Year 8 student who has asked a Learning Support Educator (LSE), Ms Borg, for the verbal prompts she normally receives, in the middle of a history assessment. Maya, Ms Borg and the history teacher are characters from the brief, so nothing here describes a real person. If you want the thinking behind the structure before reading the model text, the companion guide to approaching the BED610 ethical dilemma covers it.

Planning table

Guide question What the answer must do Approx. words Evidence to draw on
1. The dilemma State the conflict, name the two Code principles, contrast two meanings of fairness 230 Case details; Code principles three and four; MEDE inclusion policy
2. Two responses Compare repeating the usual prompts with offering no help; use example wording and judge what each reveals 270 Scaffolding and feedback literature; Webster et al. on adult support
3. Justification Defend a chosen response, meet the strongest objection, cover the next ten minutes and the longer-term agreement 340 Support plan wording; UDL guidelines; Code principle four
4. Evidence thread Woven through the sections above rather than added at the end 160 All sources, each cited where used

1. The dilemma and the two principles

Ms Borg faces a conflict between two legitimate duties with ten minutes left. Maya has said plainly that she knows what she wants to say but cannot find a way in, and the history teacher has set a task designed to show whether Maya can build an argument alone. The support plan allows instructions to be read aloud and general organisational help; it says nothing about verbal prompts in formal assessments. The gap in the plan is the dilemma.

The first principle in play is respecting the uniqueness and diversity of students. The Code asks teachers to promote fairness and equality whatever a student’s abilities (Ministry of Education and Employment [MEDE], 2012), and the national inclusion policy frames diversity as something schools value rather than merely accommodate (MEDE, 2019). The second is working collaboratively with colleagues. The Code expects cooperation with colleagues and multidisciplinary teams, which here means Ms Borg should not quietly redefine the teacher’s assessment on her own authority (MEDE, 2012).

Fairness means different things to the two adults. For Maya, fairness is access: she should not lose marks because organising written text is hard when her oral reasoning is sound. For the teacher, fairness is validity: every student’s mark should reflect the same skill, independent argument. Both views are defensible, and neither is petty. The answer should say so, because a response that treats the teacher’s concern as bureaucratic would be weak ethics.

2. Comparing two plausible responses

The first response is for Ms Borg to ask Maya her usual class questions: “What happened first?” and “What might that have caused?” The effect on the evidence is serious. Those questions carry the causal chain that the task asks Maya to construct. If she answers them aloud and writes the replies down, the script she produces records Ms Borg’s reasoning as much as her own. Prompts of this kind also work, in the sense of Wood et al. (1976), as scaffolds that take over the parts of a task the learner cannot yet manage, which is helpful in teaching and corrosive in assessment, where the scaffold is exactly what is being measured. Webster et al. (2013) found that adult support often substitutes for pupils’ own thinking rather than extending it, which is the risk here.

The second response is to decline: “I am sorry, Maya, I cannot help during an assessment.” This protects the validity of the mark, but it misreads what Maya asked for. Her difficulty is starting, not knowing, and refusing outright treats a support need as an integrity problem. Maya would very likely hand in two facts and a blank space, so the mark would describe her organisational difficulty rather than her understanding of the events. That is a reliable result for the wrong construct.

Response Example words What Maya’s answer would show
A. Usual class prompts “What happened first? What might that have caused?” Ms Borg’s causal sequence, partly rephrased by Maya
B. No help “I cannot help during an assessment.” Two facts; understanding largely hidden
C. Content-free structure (recommended) “Read the task again. Which event will you argue for? Write that in one sentence first.” Maya’s own choice, evidence and reasoning, in her order

3. Justifying the chosen response

I recommend response C: a structure that would be offered identically to any student and that contains no history. Ms Borg reads the task aloud once more, which the plan already permits, and then suggests a general organising routine: decide your choice, write it as the opening sentence, then write “because” and add one reason, then one fact that supports it. She does not say which event, which facts or how events connect. This is general organisational support, which the plan allows, and it fits the UDL guidance that learners should be supported in planning and strategy development and that scaffolds be gradually released (CAST, 2018). It also answers Hattie and Timperley’s (2007) distinction between feedback on the task and feedback on process: Ms Borg comments on the process of getting started, not on the quality of Maya’s historical answer.

The strongest objection is that any prompt, however generic, nudges Maya towards a better answer than she would otherwise have produced, so the teacher can no longer separate her thinking from Ms Borg’s. This has real force. The reply has three parts. First, the plan explicitly permits general organisational support, so the nudge is within the agreed rules, not outside them. Second, the structure is content-free: choosing an event, giving a reason and citing a fact are the very moves the task asks for, and Maya must still make each one herself. Third, the objection proves too much, since reading the question aloud is also a nudge and the teacher accepted that. The honest conclusion is that the risk cannot be removed, only reduced and made visible.

Making it visible is the immediate action. In the ten minutes available Ms Borg should give the structure, say nothing more, and write a short factual note of exactly what she said and when. She should not interrupt the teacher mid-lesson for a decision that cannot arrive in time, but she should report the note at the first opportunity so that the teacher can weigh it when marking. This honours the Code’s expectation of respectful collaboration, including not undermining a colleague’s judgement by acting silently (MEDE, 2012).

The longer-term action is a short meeting between Ms Borg and the teacher before the next assessment. They should agree in writing whether a content-free structure of this kind is permitted, which wording is acceptable, whether Maya may use a planning frame she has practised in class, and how the support will be recorded. The inclusion policy expects adaptations to be decided collaboratively between teacher and LSE (MEDE, 2019), and a written decision would remove the gap that created this dilemma. Maya’s own voice belongs in that conversation too, since she has already shown she can say what she needs.

Students working through this kind of case sometimes ask us to check an argument or structure before submission, and you can send us your brief to discuss what support suits your own task.

4. Closing evaluation

Ms Borg’s best response keeps both principles alive. It respects Maya by removing a barrier unrelated to historical understanding, and it respects the teacher by leaving every analytical decision with Maya and by reporting what happened. If you are building a similar answer, the college assignment help page, the essay writing service page and the LSE course sample on IEPs and MAPs are good places to continue.

References

CAST. (2018). Universal design for learning guidelines (Version 2.2). https://udlguidelines.cast.org

Hattie, J., & Timperley, H. (2007). The power of feedback. Review of Educational Research, 77(1), 81–112. https://doi.org/10.3102/003465430298487

Ministry of Education and Employment. (2012). Teachers’ code of ethics and practice. Government of Malta.

Ministry of Education and Employment. (2019). A policy on inclusive education in schools: Route to quality inclusion. Government of Malta.

Webster, R., Blatchford, P., & Russell, A. (2013). Challenging and changing how schools use teaching assistants: Findings from the Effective Deployment of Teaching Assistants project. School Leadership & Management, 33(1), 78–96. https://doi.org/10.1080/13632434.2012.724672

Wood, D., Bruner, J. S., & Ross, G. (1976). The role of tutoring in problem solving. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 17(2), 89–100.