A BED610 case study like the Maya and Ms Borg scenario is marked on one thing above all: whether you hold two competing duties in view at once and then commit to a defended decision. You do not win marks by deciding that one side is simply right. You win them by showing exactly what each choice costs, naming the strongest objection to your own answer, and still landing on a clear recommendation with a practical next step.
If you would rather see the approach applied than read about it, there is a BED610 model answer extract, offered for reference only. The full task wording is on the BED610 Ethical Principles for Educators assignment brief.
What the assessment is really asking
On the surface, the brief asks what Ms Borg should do when a Year 8 student who is fluent orally but struggles to organise her writing asks for the verbal prompts she usually gets. Underneath, it asks four separate things, and the grid used by a marker will follow them closely.
- Can you explain the dilemma without simply retelling the story?
- Can you compare two realistic responses using actual example wording?
- Can you justify one choice, face its best objection and give both an immediate and a longer-term action?
- Can you support all of it with case details, the principles of the Malta Teachers’ Code of Ethics and Practice, and current literature?
Two principles are named in the brief: respecting the uniqueness and diversity of students, and working collaboratively with colleagues. The Code, issued by the Ministry for Education and Employment in 2012, sets out six principles in all, and these are the third and the fourth. Treat them as lenses, not decorations. The third is about fairness for students whatever their abilities. The fourth is about cooperating with colleagues, including not undermining them. The case is built so that acting on one tempts you to neglect the other.
Most students lose marks in the first paragraph, by treating the teacher as an obstacle. The teacher is not wrong. A history task designed to test independent argument is only valid if the student does the arguing. Maya is not wrong either. Her difficulty is organising written text, not knowing the history. Say both things early.
How to split about 1,000 words
The word count is tight, so decide the split before you write a sentence. Evidence is not a separate section: it is threaded through each part, which is why the fourth row below is shown as an overlay rather than a block of extra words.
| Part | Suggested words | What earns the marks |
|---|---|---|
| 1. The dilemma and the two principles | 200 to 240 | Both views of fairness, with case details |
| 2. Two responses compared | 250 to 290 | Example words, plus what each makes Maya’s answer show |
| 3. Justification, objection, actions | 330 to 380 | A clear choice, an honest objection, then ten minutes and next term |
| 4. Evidence across all parts | Built in, about 15 per cent | Sources cited where used, never listed at the end |
Because the limit is 1,000 words with a ten per cent tolerance, you have between 900 and 1,100 words. Aim for roughly 1,000 and cut the introduction first if you are over, since the brief wants you to start answering at once.
A step plan you can follow
- Underline every concrete detail in the case: the support plan wording, the ten minutes, the teacher being busy, Maya’s exact request.
- Write one sentence stating the conflict between the two principles.
- Write one sentence each for how Maya and the teacher understand fairness.
- Draft two responses with example words you would actually say aloud.
- Test each response against one question: whose thinking would the finished script show?
- Choose, then write the strongest objection to your choice before you defend it.
- Split the action plan into the next ten minutes and the longer-term agreement.
- Add sources last, matching each to a specific claim, then trim to the limit.
Section-by-section guidance
Explaining the dilemma
Open with the conflict, not the plot. One sentence on who is involved is enough, because the marker has read the case. Then name the two principles and tie each to a detail: the support plan that allows reading aloud and general organisational help but is silent on verbal prompts, and the teacher’s stated aim of judging independent reasoning. The silence in the plan is the heart of the case, so quote or closely paraphrase it.
Comparing two responses
Pick two responses that are both plausible. A weak answer sets up a good option against an obviously bad one. A sensible pair is repeating the usual class questions against declining all help, and a stronger answer also considers a third option that sits between them. For each, give words Ms Borg might say, then state what Maya’s finished answer would reveal. That last step is where the analysis lives. Repeating the class questions supplies the causal chain the task asks Maya to build, so the answer partly reflects Ms Borg. Declining may leave the mark showing an organisational difficulty rather than understanding of the events.
Justifying your choice
Commit in the first sentence. Then explain why your choice respects both principles better than the alternatives. The best answers distinguish support with organisation from support with content, and show that the support offered would be the same for any student. Next comes the strongest objection, which is usually that even generic help nudges the answer. Do not dismiss it. Concede what is true, then explain why your choice still holds: it is permitted by the plan, it contains no subject content and it is recorded.
The immediate action and the longer-term agreement
These are two different answers and the brief wants both. With ten minutes left, what exactly does Ms Borg say and do, and how does she make her action visible to the teacher afterwards? Later, how do the LSE and the teacher agree what support is acceptable in future assessments, in writing, before the next one? Practical detail here, such as who meets whom, about what and when, separates a high mark from a pass.
Using literature without drowning in it
The brief asks for current literature on ethical practice and inclusive assessment, and every idea has to be supported. That does not mean thirty citations in 1,000 words. Use about six sources well: the Code, the national inclusive education policy, something on feedback and scaffolding, something on how adult support affects independent work, and something on accessible design in assessment. Tie each to a claim in the case.
Common mistakes
- Retelling the case for a hundred words before making a single point.
- Deciding that the teacher is rigid, or that Maya is gaming the system. The case gives no evidence for either.
- Naming the principles but never using them to reach the decision.
- Offering example wording that is vague, such as “I would support her”, instead of the words you would actually say.
- Skipping the objection, or inventing a weak one that is easy to beat.
- Giving only an immediate action, or only a long-term policy.
- Presenting a citation as a decoration at the end of a paragraph instead of backing a specific claim.
- Going well over or under the word limit, which loses marks for control of the task.
Mark-maximising checklist
- The conflict between the two principles is stated in the opening paragraph.
- Maya’s view of fairness and the teacher’s view are both explained fairly.
- Two responses are compared, each with example words.
- For each response, you say what Maya’s answer would and would not show.
- Your chosen response is stated plainly and defended.
- The strongest objection is acknowledged and answered honestly.
- Both the ten-minute action and the future agreement are specific.
- Every idea carries a citation in APA 7 style, with a matching reference list.
- The word count lands within 900 to 1,100.
Working through your own version and want a second pair of eyes on the structure? You can submit your assignment brief and we will tell you what we can do with it.
FAQs
Which two Code principles does BED610 want me to use?
The brief names respecting the uniqueness and diversity of students and working collaboratively with colleagues. These are the third and fourth of the six principles in the Teachers’ Code of Ethics and Practice, issued in 2012. Use them to explain the dilemma and to justify your decision, not just to introduce the topic.
Do I have to say Ms Borg should refuse or should help?
No. The brief asks how she should respond, and strong answers usually find a middle path. What matters is that your choice is explained, tested against an objection and shown to respect both principles.
How many sources do I need in 1,000 words?
There is no fixed number in the brief, but every idea must be supported. Around six well-chosen sources is a workable range: the Code, the national inclusion policy and a handful of academic works on feedback, support and inclusive assessment.
Should I use headings in the answer?
The brief says to organise by the guide questions, so short headings that follow them are sensible. They also help a marker see that each question has been answered.
What counts as the strongest objection?
Usually the point that even a generic prompt influences the answer, so the teacher can no longer see independent reasoning. State it fairly, then show why your response still works: it is permitted, content-free and recorded.
Is APA 7 required?
Yes, the brief specifies APA 7. Cite in the text where you use an idea and list each source in a reference list at the end of your own submission.
If you are short of time on a case like this, the college assignment help page explains what we do, or read about our essay writing service first.